Choice - Reviewed & Compared

In business since 2008, Choice Home Warranty offers homeowners an excellent home warranty service that covers all of the expected home systems, and also offers coverages for expensive-to-fix options, such as pools, spas, more appliances, and more.

Overview of Coverages and Costs

Choice Home Warranty’s basic plan covers the home systems you expect them to, such as plumbing, heating, electrical, most appliances, ductwork, etc. The Total Plan adds in the refrigerator, AC system, and washer/dryer. There are also options for pools, spas, more appliances, septic, well pumps, etc. Premiums start at $370 a year, which is a solid price.

MORE: What Home Warranty Company Is Best for You?

Positives of American Home Shield

  • No inspection necessary for a policy.
  • Uses pre-screened local contractors.
  • Service call co-pay is $60, which is on the lower end.
  • Easy online quote/application.
  • 24/7/365 claim hotline.

Any Negatives

Some consumers may want to use their own contractor, where Choice Home Warranty will insist on using their in-network contractors and repair professionals. But since they are pre-screened, we feel ok about that.

What Others Are Saying

5 stars on Trust Pilot and “Top Rated” on We like that a lot.

MORE: What Home Warranty Company Is Best for You?

Our Final Verdict: 9.9/10

Choice Home Warranty has everything you want in a home warranty company, and has good optional coverages to give you peace of mind.

  • No Annual Cap on Payouts
  • Excellent Optional Coverages
  • Really Nice Website That Makes Claims Simple